Revenue (¥ bn, bars) · net margin (%, line)
Source: securities reports
Matsumoto Oki joined Salomon Brothers out of the University of Tokyo law faculty in 1987, moved to Goldman Sachs in 1990, built its yen derivatives business almost single-handed and became a general partner in November 1994 at the age of thirty — the first educated outside the English-speaking world, founders aside. In 1998 he proposed that Goldman build an online brokerage for Japanese retail investors, was turned down, and left that November. The following May Goldman went public at a market value of about $25 billion, and partners who had stayed became rich.
He had already found his backer. Over dinner in November 1998 he put the idea to Sony’s president Idei Nobuyuki — “I barged in mid-meal,” as he put it — and Sony, which had just amended its articles to add financial services, agreed to fund half. In April 1999 the two each put up half of $439,213 (¥50m) in capital to form Monex, with fewer than ten employees and the systems outsourced. Trading began that October, the month commissions on stock trades were fully deregulated: Charles Schwab, E*Trade and DLJ had all entered Japan with local partners, and Nomura and the rest had followed, but Monex alone had neither branches nor an existing customer base to protect.
The plan rested on two assumptions — that Japanese households would shift savings toward securities as Americans had, and that internet users would grow from 27 million in 1999 to 78 million by 2005 — which together implied a flood of first-time investors. Monex kept costs down by having no branches and almost no advertising, letting news coverage bring customers instead: in the half-year to September 2000 it spent ¥65 million on advertising to add about 40,000 accounts, roughly ¥1,600 each against an industry average of ¥15,000–20,000. It differentiated with funds and underwriting rather than commissions alone, launching the first proprietary fund by an online-only broker in July 2000, and when it listed on the TSE Mothers market that August it sold most of the offering online at ¥45,000 a share by pure lottery — “the democratization of capitalism,” Matsumoto called it — adding some 18,000 individual shareholders.
Standing alone proved harder. Some sixty online brokers had entered by late 2000 and consolidation began at once; Monex merged with Saison Securities in 2001, and merger talks with DLJdirect SFG collapsed in 2002 when the two sides’ large shareholders could not agree. Matsumoto had refused to offer margin trading, holding that leverage disadvantages individuals who lack capital and speed of information. With the most accounts and the largest client assets in online broking but far fewer executions than rivals who did offer it, and an operating loss of ¥1.24 billion in the year to March 2002, he announced margin trading in June 2002 — three days before the annual meeting.